Current:Home > ScamsA Georgia death row inmate says a prosecutor hid a plea deal with a key witness, tainting his trial-DB Wealth Institute B2 Reviews & Ratings
A Georgia death row inmate says a prosecutor hid a plea deal with a key witness, tainting his trial
lotradecoin decentralized exchange features View Date:2024-12-26 05:16:19
SAVANNAH, Ga. (AP) — Attorneys for a Georgia inmate sent to death row 25 years ago are accusing a prosecutor of hiding a deal that they contend casts doubt on the credibility of a crucial trial witness.
Warren King was sentenced to death in September 1998 after an Appling County jury convicted him of murdering Karen Crosby, a convenience store clerk who was fatally shot during an armed robbery in southeast Georgia.
Now, King’s lawyers say they have evidence that the assistant district attorney who prosecuted the case, John B. Johnson, made a previously undisclosed deal with the only eyewitness to the crime. They’re asking a Superior Court judge in Butts County, home of Georgia’s death row, for a hearing in hopes of King getting a new trial.
Evidence at King’s murder trial showed that he and Walter Smith went together to rob the rural convenience store in September 1994, and that Smith brought his uncle’s gun and a mask. Both men were charged with Crosby’s murder, with King standing trial first.
Prosecutors granted Smith immunity to take the witness stand at King’s trial, and Smith told the jury it was King who shot the woman. King’s lawyers say no other witnesses or physical evidence pointed to King as the shooter.
What prosecutors didn’t disclose to defense attorneys or the trial jury is that Johnson had promised to spare Smith from a possible death sentence in exchange for his testimony, King’s lawyers said in a July 8 legal filing.
Prosecutors would have been required to disclose to defense lawyers any favorable treatment Smith received in exchange for testifying, King’s appellate lawyers said. Had King’s trial attorneys known about the deal, they could have used it to attack Smith’s credibility as a witness.
“Had this suppressed evidence been disclosed, there is a reasonable probability that the outcome of the trial would have been different,” attorney Anna Arceneaux wrote in King’s legal filing.
Arceneaux wrote that not only did prosecutors withhold knowledge of the deal from defense attorneys before the 1998 trial, but Johnson and Smith both denied its existence in remarks to the jury.
The Associated Press left a telephone message seeking comment with Johnson on Wednesday. The veteran prosecutor retired from the district attorney’s office for the Brunswick Judicial Circuit in 2021. He unsuccessfully challenged District Attorney Keith Higgins in a Republican primary election in May.
The new legal documents include an affidavit from one of Smith’s attorneys, John B. Brewer III, saying that Johnson and Smith reached a plea agreement before the trial. The terms were that Smith would receive a life sentence with a chance for parole in exchange for him testifying against King. Smith received that punishment in 2001 when he pleaded guilty to a charge of murder in Crosby’s death.
“These terms were not reduced to writing, but there was a verbal agreement,” Brewer’s affidavit said. He added: “I would never have recommended that Mr. Smith testify against Mr. King unless I knew for certain that he had a deal and would avoid the death penalty.”
According to a transcript of his closing arguments during the 1998 trial, Johnson told the jury that he would have been required to disclose any deals with Smith “because it tests his credibility.”
“There are no deals or he would have told you that,” Johnson told the trial jury. “And defense counsel would have made sure you heard that if there was one.”
King’s latest attempt to overturn his death sentence comes after the U.S. Supreme Court on July 2 declined to consider his claims that Johnson improperly excluded Black jurors during the trial. King is Black; his trial was heard by 10 white and two Black jurors.
Lower courts upheld King’s conviction and sentence after his lawyers presented evidence that Johnson used strikes to eliminate 87.5% of the eligible Black jurors for the trial and only 8.8% of the eligible white jurors, all women.
A 1986 U.S. Supreme Court decision prohibits attorneys from excluding prospective jurors based on their race. At the trial, Johnson gave other, nonracial reasons for keeping Black panelists off the jury.
In their July 8 legal filing, King’s attorneys repeat their assertion that potential Black jurors were struck because of their race. They cite new evidence: Johnson’s own handwritten notes, which they obtained last fall. The lawyers say the notes show Johnson carefully tracked which prospective jurors were Black and which were women.
King’s attorneys said Johnson took notes on how potential Black jurors answered questions about the death penalty and whether they had criminal histories. They say he didn’t make similar notes for white panelists, but rather tracked which potential white jurors had family members who were crime victims.
King’s lawyers said the prosecutor’s notes provide “concrete proof that Johnson was indeed considering race and gender” of prospective jurors.
veryGood! (6644)
Related
- Rob Schneider seeks forgiveness from daughter Elle King after 'fat camp' claims
- Pepsi Pineapple is back! Tropical soda available this summer only at Little Caesars
- Former Iowa police chief sentenced to 5 years in prison in federal gun case
- Why Simone Biles Owes Aly Raisman an Apology Ahead of the 2024 Paris Olympics
- Austin Dillon loses automatic playoff berth for actions in crash-filled NASCAR win
- You Must See Louis Tomlinson Enter His Silver Fox Era
- Steve Bannon reports to federal prison in Connecticut, says he's proud to serve his time
- Chicken Soup for the Soul Entertainment, swamped by debt, declares bankruptcy
- 'RuPaul's Drag Race Global All Stars': Premiere date, cast, where to watch and stream
- Arthur Crudup wrote the song that became Elvis’ first hit. He barely got paid
Ranking
- 'Truffles is just like me:' How a Pennsylvania cat makes kids feel proud to wear glasses
- NHL free agency highlights: Predators, Devils, others busy on big-spending day
- What to put on a sunburn — and what doctors say to avoid
- Suki Waterhouse Details Very Intense First Meeting with Robert Pattinson
- Jim Harbaugh wants to hire Colin Kaepernick to Chargers' coaching staff. Will the QB bite?
- Joseph Quinn still cringes over his 'stupid' interaction with Taylor Swift
- Hallmark's Shantel VanSanten and Victor Webster May Have the Oddest Divorce Settlement Yet
- India wins cricket Twenty20 World Cup in exciting final against South Africa
Recommendation
-
Red Cross blood inventory plummets 25% in July, impacted by heat and record low donations
-
US to pay for flights to help Panama remove migrants who may be heading north
-
Dangerously high heat builds in California and the south-central United States
-
Woman dies from being pushed into San Francisco-area commuter train
-
Ryan Reynolds on his 'complicated' relationship with his dad, how it's changed him
-
'Don’t do that to your pets': Video shows police rescue dog left inside hot trailer
-
Early Amazon Prime Day Deals 2024: Shop the Best Bedding and Linens Sales Available Now
-
Badminton Star Zhang Zhijie Dead At 17 After Collapsing On Court During Match
Tags
-
lotradecoin benefits
lotradecoin wallet setup guide
lotradecoin promotions
lotradecoin community forum discussions
lotradecoin regional trading regulations
lotradecoin versus ftx comparison
lotradecoin trading tutorial videos
lotradecoin versus other crypto exchanges
lotradecoin token listing requirements